Originally Posted by mathew
This is a logically correct question which can be followed by a logically correct answer. To my understanding your question follows this logic. Mathew is a human. Humans can eat ice-cream(in different quantities). Humans can make ice-cream. All, known and agreeable parameters. Since “Can” shows possibilities, the answer could be “Mathew cannot because Mathew will throw up if he eats ice cream more than half a pound”. But the answer you provided deals with probability rather than possibility. So I can conclude that your answer is wrong, or it does not follow a logical conclusion.
Contrary to that your question (or the question that I quoted) is, “Can God make an immovable rock?” This cannot be answered satisfactorily to both sides because, when asking such a question atheist substitute God with almighty(for arguments sake), which in the explanation we put God as almighty as well as wise, which is what my answer is. Can a wise God do foolish thing? No. Why, because he is wise and that is one of the characters that define God. God is holy so He cannot do an unholy thing. Again this is what my previous answer is. Apart from that, this kind of questions serves no purpose other than trapping an unsuspected believer.